When it comes to wood, there are two types that stand out from the rest: Oak and Walnut. Both have their own unique qualities that make them a popular choice for furniture, flooring, and other home decor items. So which one is better? Let’s take a look at the pros and cons of Oak vs Walnut to find out!
Table of Contents
What Is Oak Wood?
Oak wood is a type of hardwood that is very popular for furniture and flooring. It is a strong and durable wood that can last for many years. Oak is also a very beautiful wood with a rich grain pattern.
Oak wood is available in two main types: red oak and white oak. Red oak is the most common type of oak used in furniture and flooring. It is slightly darker in color than white oak and has a more pronounced grain pattern. White oak is less common but it is a bit lighter in color and has a smoother grain.
Oak wood is also available in two main grades: first-grade and second-grade. First-grade oak is the highest quality and has the best grain pattern. It is also the most expensive. Second-grade oak is lower quality and has a less pronounced grain pattern. It is also less expensive.
What Is Walnut Wood?
Walnut wood is a type of hardwood that is typically used in the construction of furniture and cabinets. It is also a popular choice for floors and paneling. Walnut wood has a dark brown color with a straight grain pattern.
Walnut wood is available in two main types: black walnut and walnut. Black walnut is the more expensive of the two types.
Walnut wood is available in two different grades. Grade A walnut wood is the highest quality and is typically used in high-end furniture. Grade B walnut wood is of lower quality and is often used in lower-priced furniture or for construction purposes.
Walnut wood is a hardwood that is strong and durable. It is also resistant to warping and twisting. It is easy to work with and takes stain well.
OAK VS WALNUT
| CATEGORY | OAK WOOD | WALNUT WOOD |
| PRICE | The price of Oak wood varies depending on the quality of the lumber and can range from: White Oak $8.99-$14.99/board foot Red Oak $4.39-$5.59/board foot. | The price of Walnut wood varies depending on the quality of the lumber and can range from $11.99-$20.99/board foot. You can order natural, high character and premium walnut boards. If you order in bulk you can get cheaper pricing. |
| JANKA HARDNESS | White Oak Janka Hardness score is 1360 Red Oak Janka Hardness score is 1290Walnut Janka Hardness score is 1010DURABILITYOak durability comes from its strong, hard grain. Oak is a very popular wood for furniture and flooring because of its resistance to wear and tear. | Walnut, on the other hand, is not as durable as oak. It is more susceptible to scratches and dents. However, walnut’s strength lies in its ability to resist warping and splitting. |
| SPECIES | Oak species is called Quercus and it belongs to the Fagaceae (Beech) family. | Walnut species is called Juglans and it belongs to the Juglandaceae family. |
| TREE SIZE | Oak trees can average in height from 40 to 80 feet, with a spread of about 30 to 50 feet. Oak trees have been known to live for centuries. | Walnut trees are generally smaller, averaging between 20 and 60 feet tall with a spread of 50-75 feet. Walnut tree leaves are larger, darker green, and have a rough texture. Walnut trees have a more rounded canopy. |
| LOCATION | Oak trees are grown in many different locations including Europe, Asia, and North America. Oak trees prefer a temperate climate with moist soil. | Walnut trees are native to the Mediterranean region but are also grown in other parts of the world including North America, Europe, and Asia. Walnut trees prefer a temperate climate with well-drained soil. |
| COLOR | Oak wood is typically a light to golden brown color. Oak wood may also have a slight reddish hue to it. Oak wood’s color is affected by its growing environment. Oak that grows in the forest will be a darker brown than Oak grown on a farm. The tannins in Oak also give it color variations from white to black. | Walnut wood is typically a chocolate brown color with darker streaks running through it. Walnut wood may also have a slightly purple hue to it. Walnut, on the other hand, has a more consistent color. It is usually a dark chocolate brown but can also be found in lighter shades. |
| GRAIN | Oak wood grain is very unique. The grain is straight and made up of small, tightly packed pores. Oak is a hardwood, so the grain is also very strong and durable. | Walnut wood grain is straight grained and pores are much larger and more spaced out. Walnut is also a hardwood, but the grain is not as strong and durable as oak. |
| END GRAIN | Oak End Grain is porous, with large, irregular pores arranged in a radial pattern. Oak also has a wide range of colors and grain patterns. | Walnut End Grain is smooth, with small, uniform pores arranged in a spiral pattern. Walnut also has a limited range of colors and grain patterns. |
| ROT RESISTANCE | Oak has some rot resistance due to its high tannin content. Tannins are a natural preservative that give oak wood its characteristic dark color. Oak is more porous than walnut, making it more susceptible to rot. Despite its reputation, Oak is not immune to rot. Oak wood will eventually succumb to rot if it is not properly maintained. | Walnut wood also has a high tannin content, but not as much as oak. Walnut’s rot resistance comes from its dense, hard nature. Walnut, on the other hand, is much more resistant to rot and decay. If you are looking for a wood that will last a lifetime, walnut is the way to go. |
| ODOR | Oak wood generally smells like vinegar but you might get a faint whiff of vanilla or almond from the tannins, but mostly it just smells like vinegar. After it’s kiln dried the smell is reduced. | Walnut wood can have a foul odor that some have described as rotting meat or cat feces when it’s freshly cut from the tree. After it’s kiln dried the smell is reduced. |
| SUSTAINABILITY | Oak wood is sustainable because it is an abundant resource that is easy to replace. | Walnut wood is not as sustainable because it is a less common resource and takes longer to grow. |
| USES | Oak wood is used for a variety of things including flooring, furniture, cabinetry, wine barrels, boats and even smoking meats. Oak is a very strong wood that can last for many years with proper care. | Walnut wood can be used for furniture, cabinetry, gunstocks, veneers, interior paneling, cutting boards, marquetry inlays, checkboards, flooring, millwork, desks, dining tables and butcher blocks. |
| RELATED SPECIESOak wood related species are found in the northern hemisphere and have 500 related species including white oak, red oak, and live oak. Oak trees are deciduous. | Walnut related species are found mostly in the southern hemisphere but some grow in the northern hemisphere as well. There are about 30 related species of walnut including black walnut, butternut, and heartnut. walnuts are evergreen. |
OAK VS WALNUT: PROS & CONS
| OAK | WALNUT | |
| PROS | The pros of Oak wood are that it is very strong and durable. Oak is also a popular choice for furniture because it has a beautiful grain pattern. Oak can be stained or painted to match any decor. | The pros of Walnut wood are that it is very strong and durable. Walnut is also a popular choice for furniture because it has a beautiful grain pattern. Walnut can be stained or painted to match any decor. |
| CONS | The cons of Oak are that it is susceptible to scratches and dents. Oak is also a bit more expensive than some other types of wood. | The cons of Walnut are that it is susceptible to scratches and dents. Walnut is also a bit more expensive than some other types of wood. |
Is Walnut More Expensive Than Oak?
Yes, walnut is more expensive than oak. Oak is a very common type of wood, so it is more affordable. Walnut is not as common, so it tends to cost more.
It’s also more difficult to find because it’s not as widely available. Oak is the more popular choice for furniture and flooring because it’s less expensive and more durable. Walnut is a good choice for people who are looking for a unique look.
Is Oak Or Walnut Better For Furniture?
Oak is better for furniture because of it’s affordability and strength compared to Walnut. Oak is also more resistant to scratches and dents. Walnut is a little more expensive but it’s a beautiful wood that will make your furniture stand out. Oak is the better choice for furniture if you’re looking for value and durability.
Oak and walnut are two of the most popular hardwoods used in furniture making. Each has its own unique grain pattern and color, making it a favorite among woodworkers. Oak is a strong, sturdy wood that is often used in creating heavy pieces of furniture such as tables and chairs. Walnut, on the other hand, is a softer wood that is more suited for intricate carving and detailed work.
So, which is the better choice for your next furniture project? Let’s take a closer look at each type of wood to see how they compare.
Oak is one of the strongest woods on the market, making it a great choice for pieces that will see a lot of use. Oak is also very resistant to rot and insect damage, making it a durable option for outdoor furniture. Walnut is not as strong as oak, but it is still a sturdy wood that can handle a fair amount of wear and tear. Walnut is also less likely to warp or crack than other types of wood, making it a good choice for pieces that will be exposed to moisture.
When it comes to looks, oak and walnut are both beautiful woods that can add a touch of elegance to any room. Oak has a classic look that never goes out of style, while walnut has a more modern appeal. Oak is available in a variety of colors, from light blond to rich brown. Walnut is usually a dark chocolate brown, but it can also be found in lighter shades.
Is Walnut Darker Than Oak?
Yes, walnut is darker than oak. Oak is light brown while walnut is dark brown. Walnut also has a more pronounced grain than oak.
If you’re trying to decide between the two for your home, it really comes down to personal preference. If you want a darker wood, go with walnut. If you prefer a lighter wood, oak is the way to go.
Recommended Posts:
