Pin Oak and Red Oak are two types of oak trees that are commonly found in North America. Pin Oaks are typically found in the east, while Red Oaks are more common in the west. While they share some similarities, there are also some key differences between these two types of oak trees.
In this article we will discuss Pin Oak Wood vs Red Oak Wood.
Table of Contents
What Is Pin Oak Wood?
Pin Oak wood is a type of hardwood that is commonly used in construction and furniture making. It is a strong and durable wood that is resistant to rot and decay. Pin Oak wood is also easy to work with, making it a popular choice for many woodworking projects.
It’s native to North America and grows in abundance in the eastern United States. Pin oaks are a member of the oak family (Quercus), which also includes other popular hardwoods such as red oak, white oak, and black oak.
Subscribe to University of Illinois Extension FJPRW on YouTube
What Is Red Oak Wood?
Red oak is a type of hardwood that comes from the Quercus rubra tree. This tree is native to North America and can be found in a variety of habitats, from woodlands to wetlands. The red oak tree can grow to be quite large, reaching heights of up to 100 feet (30 meters).
Red Oak wood is one of the most popular types of wood used in construction and furniture making. It is strong and durable, yet still has a beautiful grain that makes it perfect for a variety of applications.
The wood of the red oak tree is strong and dense, making it perfect for a number of different uses.
PIN OAK VS RED OAK
| CATEGORY | PIN OAK WOOD | RED OAK WOOD |
| PRICE | The price of Pin Oak wood varies depending on the quality of the lumber and is priced similar to Red Oak wood. | The price of Red Oak wood varies depending on the quality of the lumber and can range from $4.39-$5.59/board foot. You can order natural, high character and premium walnut boards. If you order in bulk you can get cheaper pricing. |
| JANKA HARDNESS | Pin Oak Janka Hardness is 1500 | Red Oak Janka Hardness is 1220 |
| DURABILITY | Pin Oak is more durable than Red Oak but still less durable compared to White Oak. It is more resistant to pests and rot, making it a better choice for outdoor furniture. Pin Oak is also less likely to warp and split than Red Oak. | Red Oak is more likely to dent and scratch, and it shows wear more easily. If you’re looking for a more durable hardwood floor, White Oak is the better choice. |
| SPECIES | Pin Oak species is Quercus Palustris | Red Oak species is Quercus rubra. |
| TREE SIZE | Pin Oak trees average between 50-75 feet and 2-4 feet in diameter. Red Oak trees are considerably larger. | Red Oak trees average between 80-115 feet tall and 3-6 feet in diameter. In terms of sheer size, the red oak is the clear winner. |
| LOCATION | Pin Oak trees are located in the eastern and central United States. Pin Oak trees prefer to grow in moist soils that are well-drained. | Red oaks are located in the northern, southern, and western United States. They can tolerate a wider range of soil conditions including dryer soils. |
| COLOR | Pin oak wood is a light tan to pale brown. | Red Oak is reddish with light to medium brown heartwood and white to pale yellow sapwood. |
| GRAIN | Pin Oak grain is much more apparent than that of Red Oak. The pores in Pin Oak are large and open, while those in Red Oak are much smaller. This gives Pin Oak a coarser grain, which is why it’s often used for construction purposes. Pin oak has a medium-coarse texture with large pores. | Red oak wood grain is also straight with a slightly more pronounced wave to it. This grain is what gives red oak wood its unique character and beauty. |
| END GRAIN | Pin Oak end grain is ring porous. The pores are large and open, making it a good candidate for staining. | Red Oak is also ring porous, but the pores are not as uniformly distributed and the rays are smaller, resulting in a smoother grain. |
| ROT RESISTANCE | Pin Oak has a lower level of rot resistance compared to white oak and similar to Red Oak, making it more susceptible to decay. The most common type of rot found in pin oaks is white rot, which breaks down the lignin in the wood, causing it to turn white. Pin oaks are also susceptible to brown rot, which attacks the cellulose in the wood, causing it to turn brown. | Red Oak has weak rot resistance due to its low tannin content. This means that it will not last as long in wet or humid environments as White Oak and is prone to insect attacks. |
| SUSTAINABILITY | Both are equally sustainable and abundant in North America. Pin Oak (Quercus palustris) is more drought-tolerant than Red Oak (Quercus rubra), making it a good choice for regions with limited water resources. | Both are equally sustainable and abundant in North America. Pin Oak (Quercus palustris) is more drought-tolerant than Red Oak (Quercus rubra), making it a good choice for regions with limited water resources. |
| USES | Both are used primarily in the same way such as for construction lumber, hardwood floors, and cabinets. The wood from each is very similar in hardness, weight, and strength. The key difference lies in the grain pattern and color. | Both are used primarily in the same way such as for construction lumber, hardwood floors, and cabinets. The wood from each is very similar in hardness, weight, and strength. The key difference lies in the grain pattern and color. |
| RELATED SPECIES | Pin oak also has many related species such as the willow oak, the water oak, and the shumard oak. All these oaks are very similar in appearance to the pin oak. The main difference between these trees is their leaves. Pin oaks have glossy green leaves with sharply pointed lobes. Willow oaks have long, slender leaves that are a bluish-green color. | Red oak also has many related species such as the black oak, scarlet oak, and shumard oak. |
PIN OAK VS RED OAK: PROS & CONS
| PIN OAK WOOD | RED OAK WOOD | |
| PROS | The pros of Pin Oak wood are that it is very strong and affordable. It is also a very beautiful wood with a rich grain pattern. | The pros of Red Oak wood are that it is very popular and easy to find. It is also cheaper than White Oak wood. |
| CONS | The cons of Pin Oak wood are that it is susceptible to insects and rot. It is also not as widely available as other types of oak wood. | The cons of Red Oak wood are that it is not as strong and durable as White Oak wood. |
What Are The Differences Between Pin Oak vs Red Oak?
When it comes to the differences between Pin Oak vs Red Oak, there are a few things to keep in mind.
The most notable difference is the size. Pin oaks are much smaller, only reaching a height of about 50-75 feet. Red oaks, on the other hand, can grow up to 80-115 feet tall.
Another difference between these two types of oak trees is their leaves. Pin oak leaves are usually about four inches long and have a deep notch in the center. Red oak leaves are much larger, often reaching up to eight inches in length. They also have a shallow notch in the center of the leaf.
Finally, another difference to take note of is the acorns. Pin oaks have acorns that are about half an inch long and take two years to mature. Red oak acorns are much larger, usually around an inch long, and take only one year to mature.
What Are The Similarities Between Pin Oak vs Red Oak?
When it comes to the similarities between Pin Oak vs Red Oak, there are a few things to know.
For starters, both of these trees are deciduous and grow in North America. They also have similar leaves, with each leaf having around five to seven lobes. The bark on both trees is also a dark brown or black color.
Pin Oak wood is best for:
-Veneer
-Flooring
-Furniture
Because of its tight grain and light color, pin oak is often used in veneer applications. It’s also a popular choice for flooring and furniture, thanks to its durability and stylish look. If you’re looking for a beautiful hardwood that will last for years to come, pin oak is a great option.
Red Oak wood is best for:
-Furniture
-Flooring
-Veneer
Red Oak is one of the most popular woods used in America for good reason. It’s strong, durable, and beautiful. If you’re looking for wood to use for furniture, flooring, or firewood, Red Oak is a great option.
Is Pin Oak The Same As Red Oak?
No, Pin Oak is not the same as Red Oak although they are very similar and are a related species.
Pin Oaks tend to be smaller in stature and have a more slender trunk. The leaves of Pin Oaks are also narrower than those of Red Oaks. Finally, the acorns of Pin Oaks mature a year earlier than those of Red Oak trees.
Interesting Facts on Pin Oak Trees
Subscribe to Brainy.Garden on YouTube
Recommended Posts:
