Subscribe to DIY with Dave on YouTube
Lumber Liquidators, once a billion-dollar company with over 400 stores, is now out of business. Founded in 1994 by Tom Sullivan, a building contractor, the company rose to prominence by selling affordable flooring, capitalizing on the growing demand for home improvement products. However, its downfall can be attributed to a series of illegal and unethical practices that tarnished its reputation and ultimately led to its closure.
Key Takeaways:
- Growth Isn’t Always Sustainable: Lumber Liquidators expanded rapidly, but they resorted to illegal practices to maintain their profit margins.
- Public Scrutiny: Once a company goes public, it must be transparent with its financials. Suspicious trends, like increasing profit margins without rising costs, can trigger investigations.
- Unethical Sourcing: Lumber Liquidators’ illegal sourcing of wood from endangered forests not only damaged the environment but also led to significant fines and legal trouble.
- Health Hazards: The company’s use of formaldehyde-laden flooring posed serious health risks to consumers, leading to a major lawsuit and further financial penalties.
- Reputation Matters: Even after rebranding, Lumber Liquidators struggled to shake its tarnished image. The company’s reputation was damaged beyond repair, contributing to its eventual bankruptcy.
- Market Pressures: Home improvement is a cyclical industry that fluctuates with the housing market. Lumber Liquidators was especially vulnerable due to its legal and financial issues, compounded by a decline in home buying and renovation.
The Beginnings of Lumber Liquidators
Tom Sullivan started the company by buying excess wood at low prices and selling it from the back of a truck. Over the next two decades, Lumber Liquidators expanded rapidly, opening hundreds of stores across the U.S. and Canada. The company went public in 2007, and by 2014, its revenue had grown from $100 million to over $1 billion. Customers were drawn to the company’s low-cost hardwood flooring, and the business thrived.
A Shady Business Model
Despite its success, Lumber Liquidators engaged in illegal practices that allowed them to sell products at a lower price than competitors. One investor noticed that while the company’s revenues were rising, its costs weren’t increasing at the same rate—a red flag in the industry. This discrepancy led to the discovery that Lumber Liquidators had been illegally sourcing materials, including wood from endangered forests in Russia.
The company was implicated in a major environmental crime in which Russian lumber was harvested from protected forests, home to the last remaining Siberian tigers. Lumber Liquidators purchased the wood through Chinese suppliers, violating the Lacey Act. The company pled guilty and paid $133 million in fines in 2015.
The Formaldehyde Scandal
If environmental crimes weren’t enough, another scandal soon followed. Lumber Liquidators was caught selling laminate flooring from China that contained dangerously high levels of formaldehyde, a known carcinogen. Some flooring tested had formaldehyde levels up to 20 times above the legal limit, putting consumers’ health at serious risk. The company denied the allegations at first, but after multiple lawsuits and federal penalties, they were forced to settle a class action lawsuit for $36 million and pay a $33 million penalty for misleading investors.
Financial Decline and Rebranding
After the scandals, Lumber Liquidators struggled to recover. From 2015 to 2018, the company reported consistent financial losses, partly due to the fines and lawsuits, but also because of reputational damage. To distance itself from its tainted past, the company rebranded as “LL Flooring” in 2020. Although the rebranding helped somewhat during the pandemic, when many home improvement businesses thrived, the company’s underlying issues remained.
In 2022, LL Flooring saw sales drop by 17%, and in 2023, sales fell by another 19%. Rising costs and falling revenue made it difficult for the company to stay afloat, leading to its bankruptcy filing in August 2023. While the company sought a buyer to save its business, no significant offers came forward.
Subscribe to 731 Woodworks on Youtube
The Final Chapter
In late 2023, LL Flooring announced it would liquidate its assets and close down. However, just as the company prepared to shut its doors, a private equity firm led by Tom Sullivan, the company’s founder, stepped in to buy out LL Flooring. Sullivan’s firm is expected to purchase about 200 of the stores, leaving the fate of the remaining locations uncertain. Whether this new ownership will lead to a successful turnaround or further decline remains to be seen.
Lumber Liquidators’ story is a cautionary tale about the importance of ethical business practices, transparency, and long-term planning. While the company is now being liquidated, its legacy serves as a reminder of the consequences of cutting corners and prioritizing profits over people and the environment.