Subscribe to wittworks on YouTube
In a refreshingly candid video, a seasoned woodworker shares an unconventional review of cordless track saws, including models from Ryobi, Rigid, Milwaukee, DeWalt, Festool, and Makita. Known for their reluctance to follow the typical review formula, the creator focuses on the practical performance, design quirks, and real-life usability of each saw. They also address industry hype and influencer biases, delivering an unapologetically honest perspective.
For those navigating the overwhelming world of track saw options, this video provides a no-nonsense guide that cuts through the noise—no affiliate links or brand sponsorships influencing the opinions here.
Key Takeaways
- Not All Track Saws Are Equal:
- While all track saws can cut plywood effectively with a sharp blade and intact splinter guard, performance differences emerge when cutting hardwoods like maple.
- The motor strength, blade type, and user experience vary significantly between models.
- Blade Choice Matters More Than You Think:
- The creator emphasizes the importance of using the correct blade for the job. A thin-kerf ripping blade consistently outperformed stock cross-cut blades when cutting thick hardwoods.
- Honest Reviews vs. Industry Hype:
- The video critiques influencer reviews for often glossing over shortcomings, especially when tools are gifted or reviewed with affiliate incentives.
- Cordless vs. Corded:
- While cordless saws offer convenience, they often fall short in power compared to corded models. The Festool TS 60 corded saw remains the creator’s personal favorite for its unmatched power and precision.
- Manufacturer Highlights and Shortcomings:
- Ryobi: Affordable but feels like a toy. Its two-piece track design and incompatible dust ports are major drawbacks.
- Rigid: Great build quality and accurate cuts, but struggles with motor and battery overheating under heavy loads.
- Milwaukee: Near-perfect design and performance, with the best motor in the lineup. However, lacks Bluetooth connectivity for dust extractors.
- DeWalt: Innovative but unnecessarily overcomplicated. The plunge mechanism and track design deviate from industry standards.
- Makita: Excellent build quality and dual-arbor compatibility but lacks a ring knife or effective anti-kickback system.
- Festool: The gold standard with unparalleled build quality, dust extraction, and electronic anti-kickback, but comes at a premium price.
- Stress Testing with “Tiny Shawn”:
- The creator uses a 2-inch thick piece of hard maple, nicknamed “Tiny Shawn,” as a stress test for saw motors. This unconventional method highlights each saw’s capability under challenging conditions.
- Top Pick:
- For cordless saws, Milwaukee takes the crown for its motor quality, ease of use, and accurate depth adjustments. However, the creator notes Festool’s Bluetooth integration with dust extractors as a game-changing feature.
What Makes This Review Different?
- No Sponsorship Bias: The creator purchased all 20 saws reviewed in the video, spending over $4,900 out of pocket. This independence ensures an unbiased perspective.
- Custom Aftermarket Solutions: Many shortcomings, such as poor dust collection, were addressed with 3D-printed accessories designed by the creator. These solutions are available for purchase but not required for an honest review.
- Real-World Testing: Instead of lab-like precision, the tests reflect real woodworking scenarios, making the insights more applicable to everyday users.
Who Should Watch This Video?
This video is a must-watch for woodworkers, DIYers, and anyone frustrated with generic review content. The creator’s practical, down-to-earth approach provides clarity in a sea of marketing jargon, helping viewers make informed decisions based on their needs, budget, and existing tool ecosystems.
Final Thoughts
Cordless track saws are a modern luxury, but their effectiveness depends on your specific needs. Whether you prioritize motor strength, dust extraction, or guide rail compatibility, this video lays out all the details to help you choose wisely.