Subscribe to The Honest Carpenter on YouTube
Key Takeaways
- Wood rot is caused by fungi, not age or dryness.
- Moisture is essential for wood rot to develop—no moisture, no rot.
- “Dry rot” is a misused term and doesn’t exist—what people mean is usually brown rot.
- Homeowners can and should learn to identify rot themselves.
- Scare tactics around wood rot are common—don’t fall for unnecessary repairs.
The Most Misunderstood Threat to Your Home: Wood Rot
Wood rot—two small words that strike fear into homeowners across the country. Yet, despite its prevalence, wood rot remains one of the most misunderstood issues in home maintenance. Ethan James of TheHonestCarpenter.com, a seasoned carpenter specializing in home repairs, believes that the confusion surrounding wood rot has left homeowners vulnerable to bad advice—and worse, dishonest contractors.
In a recent video, Ethan dives deep into the real story behind wood rot: what causes it, how to spot it, and most importantly, how to prevent it. The root of the confusion? Most homeowners don’t actually know what wood rot looks like, or where it comes from. That lack of understanding leaves them open to overspending on unnecessary repairs.
What Really Causes Wood Rot?
Contrary to popular belief, wood rot doesn’t just happen over time or due to dryness. In fact, dry rot is a misleading term. The true cause? Fungus—and fungus requires one critical ingredient to thrive: moisture.
Fungi responsible for rot love temperatures between 50–90°F, which makes the interior of most homes an ideal breeding ground. However, without a consistent moisture source, fungi can’t activate or spread.
That’s why “dry rot” is a myth. What’s often called dry rot is technically brown rot, caused by the fungus Serpula lacrymans. It makes wood brittle and crumbly, but it cannot spread unless moisture is present. So if a contractor tells you that “dry rot spreads without water,” consider it a red flag.
Moisture is the Real Enemy
If you remember one thing from this blog post, let it be this:
Wood cannot rot without moisture.
Cutting off the water source is the first and most crucial step in stopping rot. Once the wood dries, the fungal growth ceases. That’s why good contractors prioritize fixing leaks—whether from plumbing, roofing, or exterior exposure—before any carpentry work begins.
How to Identify Wood Rot (And Avoid Getting Ripped Off)
Learning to identify wood rot can save homeowners thousands of dollars in unnecessary repairs. Ethan outlines several simple methods anyone can use:
Visual Inspection
Look for:
- Dark spots or discoloration
- Warped or deformed areas
- Small holes or cavities
- A pulpy or spongy texture
- Cracked or blistering surfaces (especially on painted wood)
The Poke Test
Using your finger, press on the suspected area. If the wood feels soft or spongy, it’s likely rotting.
The Pick Test
Use a pocketknife or screwdriver to probe deeper. If the tool sinks easily or if the wood breaks into crumbles rather than long splinters, it may be decayed.
Sound Test
Healthy wood will make a snapping or cracking sound when probed. Rotten wood sounds mushy or rustling.
When It’s Not Wood Rot
Sometimes what looks like rot is just cosmetic damage. For example, peeling paint or failing caulk on siding might seem like decay but could simply be sun damage. These surfaces may look rough but remain structurally sound. A basic scrape-and-paint job is all that’s needed—not a full replacement.
Common Wood Rot Scams to Watch Out For
Unfortunately, some contractors exploit the fear of rot. They might exaggerate the spread of so-called “dry rot” and recommend replacing large sections of perfectly good wood. Always verify the presence of moisture and perform a visual or poke test before agreeing to extensive repairs.
Remember: If the wood is dry, the rot can’t spread.
Final Thoughts: Be Informed, Stay Empowered
Wood rot is a legitimate concern—but it’s also manageable. Knowing how to identify and address it puts power back in the hands of homeowners. Don’t let fear or misinformation drive costly decisions. With a little knowledge and a few simple tools, you can protect your home and your wallet.