Subscribe to Hamilton Dilbeck on YouTube
In a crowded maker space full of creative woodworking projects, few items have stirred as much interest—and as many follow-up questions—as the humble whiskey smoker. What started as a basic CNC-cut gift item quickly became a repeat best-seller at local markets and shops. Despite initial doubts and plenty of saturation, the product’s simplicity, versatility, and profit margin have turned it into a staple offering for makers and small woodworking businesses.
This blog post explores one creator’s entire process—from design and production to packaging, pricing, and sales strategy—for building and selling white oak whiskey smokers. It’s a deep dive into how a single well-crafted idea can deliver consistent revenue with limited CNC time.
🔑 Key Takeaways
- High-Profit Margins: With a cost of ~$5.50 per unit and a selling price of $25–$30, the product yields a strong profit margin.
- Simple CNC Workflow: The design uses only two bits and minimal finishing, allowing high production efficiency.
- Customizable = More Sales: Personalization options like custom initials or logos allow an extra $5–$10 per item.
- Impulse Buy Pricing Sweet Spot: Keeping the price under $30 encourages quick decision-making from customers.
- Real-World Validation: One Etsy seller has made over $1,400 in profit selling this exact design with minimal investment.
From Concept to Sell-Out Success
The white oak whiskey smoker wasn’t the first of its kind, but this particular version gained attention after it sold out at a local market. It all began as an experiment with design and efficiency using an affordable CNC machine, and quickly evolved into a sought-after product.
Using FAS-grade white oak, the highest quality available, the maker could fill a full CNC bed with 64 units per run. Each batch took about three hours to cut. With a rough cost breakdown of $3 per unit in CNC time and $2 in materials (plus another $0.50 for bags, mesh, and finishing), the all-in cost landed at around $5.50 per unit.
Design Evolution & Customer Feedback
The design transitioned from a minimalist form to one that includes text like “White Oak Whiskey Smoker” engraved across the top—something buyers strongly preferred. A notable change was removing roundovers to speed up production time.
Customization became a powerful sales driver. Buyers could add initials, names, or logos for a small upcharge, making it an ideal gift item. This flexibility helped fuel demand in both market settings and online stores.
Efficient Finishing & Assembly
Each smoker is finished with mineral oil—a food-safe, heat-resistant option that also adds to the product’s aesthetic without impacting the smoking experience. After brushing off CNC fuzzies and sanding edges, the units are oiled, dried in a compact station, and then paired with a stainless steel mesh insert.
The mesh holds up over 100+ uses and friction-fits into the smoker base. A cloth drawstring bag completes the kit, replacing previous plastic packaging that caused moisture issues in the sun.
Pricing Strategy: Maximizing Impulse Buys
Originally sold for $20, the price was increased to $25 with zero noticeable drop in sales. For spring markets, the creator plans a bundle deal: $25 each or 3 for $60—a psychological sweet spot for gift shoppers.
At pop-up shops, chip refills are sold for $5, with approximately 10% of buyers opting in. The chips were upgraded from white oak to maple, which burns cleaner and looks better, improving the user experience.
Lessons from Selling (and Not Selling) Torches
A failed experiment with selling $15 torches highlighted a crucial insight: bundling expensive accessories kills impulse purchases. Adding a QR code for torch recommendations proved to be a better strategy than physically stocking and selling them.
Shipping & Online Sales Potential
The small size of the whiskey smoker makes it ideal for compact 4x6x2-inch boxes, keeping shipping costs around $6–$8. This makes selling online feasible with a suggested price of $30, maintaining healthy margins.
An Etsy seller who used the same file has already sold 85 units for $30 each, proving the scalability and demand for this product.
Final Thoughts: Why It Works
This whiskey smoker works not just because of its function—but because it’s efficient to make, easy to sell, and customizable for any occasion. Its compact design, profitable pricing, and personal touch make it an ideal product for CNC owners looking to turn side projects into real income.
For those looking to dive deeper, the file pack includes multiple design variations, ready-to-print directions, and marketing assets. And for makers serious about scaling up, a full course on CNC product sales is expected soon from the creator behind the project.