Subscribe to Lincoln St. Woodworks on YouTube
Four years ago, a popular woodworking creator advised beginners to avoid Harbor Freight’s bottom-tier tools. The backlash was immediate. Loyal fans of the budget-friendly retailer filled the comment section, defending their favorite store and roasting him for being, in their words, a “tool snob.”
But what if those fans were right? Determined to find out, he returned to Harbor Freight, spent a small fortune on their most popular woodworking tools, and put them to the test in real workshop conditions. After two days of building, sanding, and questioning his past judgments, the results were eye-opening.
Key Takeaways 🔧
- Not All Tools Are Equal – Some Harbor Freight tools impressed with build quality and value, while others fell short.
- Hercules Planer Shines – The 12½-inch Hercules planer performed admirably for its price, rivaling more expensive competitors.
- Table Saw Disappointments – The lack of a portable stand and limited dado capacity made the Hercules job site table saw a pass.
- Mixed Bag on Small Tools – Clamps and the Bower miter gauge showed promise, while the Hercules router revealed design flaws.
- Dust Extractor Wins – The 12-gallon dust extractor was the standout performer, combining suction power with quiet operation.
- Warranty Matters – Harbor Freight’s shorter warranties often undercut value compared to premium brands, unless extended.
First Impressions: Hercules Planer
The Hercules 12½-inch planer was the first test, and it made a strong case for Harbor Freight. Its beefy steel construction, accurate infeed/outfeed tables, and thoughtful carriage lock all delivered features often reserved for pricier models.
Performance-wise, it handled light passes with ease. On denser woods like sapele, however, heavier cuts led to tear-out. Dust collection left something to be desired, but for $400 (and often less with Harbor Freight’s infamous coupons), the planer proved to be a solid buy.
Verdict: Surprisingly good. Worth the savings compared to the DeWalt 734 if you can catch it on sale.
The Table Saw: Where It Falls Short
The Hercules job site table saw came in at $350 and looked suspiciously like a DeWalt clone—right down to the rack-and-pinion fence. Out of the box, the saw performed adequately, but deeper issues surfaced:
- No portable stand option (a huge miss for a “job site” saw).
- Short arbor limited dado stacks to just ¼ inch.
- Sticky fence and less refined adjustments compared to competitors.
Verdict: A functional saw, but missing critical features. For many woodworkers, it’s a dealbreaker.
Smaller Tools: Hits and Misses
Hercules Router
The cordless Hercules router was a letdown. Cheap-feeling knobs, an awkward switch placement, and a loose locking pin made it frustrating to use. While it worked for basic edge profiles, it couldn’t compete with more refined brands like DeWalt or Makita.
Verdict: Skip this one.
Parallel Clamps
The 24-inch Bremen parallel clamps, priced at $30, delivered decent performance. They held tight, offered adequate clamping force, and were backed by Harbor Freight’s lifetime guarantee.
Verdict: Surprisingly good for the price—though not replacing high-end clamps anytime soon.
Bower Miter Gauge
At $59.99, the Bower miter gauge cut accurate 90° and 45° angles in testing, though adjustment knobs felt cheap and quality control varied. For beginners, it was a budget-friendly win.
Verdict: A strong buy if you land a square unit.
Power Tools & Battery Platforms
Harbor Freight’s Hercules drill delivered reliable performance and an industry-leading five-year limited warranty. But the Achilles’ heel wasn’t the drill itself—it was the small ecosystem of just 27 compatible tools.
Verdict: Good drill, but committing to Hercules’ battery platform limits future flexibility compared to brands like Makita or Ryobi with 300+ tools.
The Crown Jewel: 12-Gallon Dust Extractor
The standout of the entire haul was the Hercules 12-gallon OSHA-compliant dust extractor. At $350, it offered:
- Auto on/off syncing with tools.
- Filter self-cleaning.
- Generous accessories and hose length.
- Quiet operation compared to a standard shop vac.
Yes, the 90-day warranty was short unless extended, but overall this tool exceeded expectations and became the reviewer’s favorite Harbor Freight purchase.
Verdict: A must-buy for woodworkers tired of loud, inefficient shop vacs.
Was He Wrong About Harbor Freight?
After a full test drive, the results were split. Some tools truly impressed, others left room for improvement, and a few were hard passes. The final tally leaned slightly in favor of the Harbor Freight fanboys—four wins to three losses.
The lesson? Don’t dismiss or glorify a brand entirely. Harbor Freight can offer surprising value, but careful selection is key. For beginners or hobbyists, some tools deliver serious bang for the buck, while pros may still gravitate toward premium brands.
At the end of the day, the only guaranteed winner was Harbor Freight itself—thanks to another hefty checkout receipt.